How IHOP Can Learn From New Coke

IHOP’s recent much anticipated name change caused a stir among consumers and marketing experts alike. When it was finally announced, after a viral social media campaign, that the “B” that would replace the “P” in IHOP, the internet went wild. The backlash online was swift– and quickly turned into a running joke not only with fans, but with several other fast food marketing departments, as well.

The question with many people remains—why not stick with what you’re good at? Many IHOP fans voiced their hopes for an expansion into the ever-popular brunch industry, among other exciting ideas. Negative feedback from an unexpected product, however, is nothing new for American consumers. Time and again brands seeking relevancy use sometimes radical efforts to improve something that didn’t need improving.

The New Coke campaign of the 1980s is a prime example of a company addressing the wrong problems of a brand. In 1985, for example, the Coca Cola Company had lost about 24% of its market share in the soda industry since World War II. This sharp decline was a direct result of the dramatic increase in sales of Pepsi-Cola as well as the introduction of new “diet” drinks.

The situation left Coke marketing executives scrambling for ways to regain ground in the industry. As a result, the President and VP of Marketing commissioned a project to test a new coke flavor to replace the original. While the surveys conducted were initially positive, taste tests and focus groups increasingly showed contempt over not just the flavor change, but the identity lost with the brand as well.

What many at the company didn’t realize was just how much certain large demographics of consumers connected with Coke. The Coca Cola hotline, which typically receives around 400 calls a day, was swamped with as many as 1,500 calls from customers in such dismay at the change. A psychiatrist hired by the company to analyze the response noted, “ some people sounded as if they were discussing the death of a family member”.[ (The Real Story of New Coke, n.d.)  .

As was inevitable, 78 days after the launch of “New Coke,” Coca Cola announced an end to their campaign and returned to using the classic formula while selling the new version separately. As a result, Coca Cola experienced a sales growth at more than double Pepsi’s a mere six months later. The lesson here is that Coke forgot who they were, and they underestimated the importance of that identity to their consumers.

IHOP, in its latest rebranding effort, seems to be making the same mistake. Since the “P” in IHOP stands for “pancakes,” to most of us, IHOP without pancakes is just another diner. If they learn anything from the New Coke debacle, the hope is that they improve upon their bread-and-butter—the breakfast menu and the source of the beloved P in their identity—before tackling the burger menu.

Bibliography

The Real Story of New Coke. (n.d.). Retrieved 6 15, 2018, from The Coca-Cola Company: http://www.coca-colacompany.com/stories/coke-lore-new-coke

Follow us on social media for the latest updates in B2B!

Image

Latest

What Super Bowl 59 Taught Us About UGC
What Super Bowl 59 Taught Us About UGC
February 11, 2025

In this episode of UGC for B2B, host Logan King sits down with Game Changers podcast host Katie Steinberg, who attended Super Bowl 59 and witnessed firsthand how User-Generated Content (UGC) is transforming the fan experience. Katie shares her experience in New Orleans, describing the electric atmosphere, the immersive fan activations, and the way content…

Read More
Kathryn O'Day
Ironman Mindset for Success with Kathryn O’Day | Ep. 24 | Growthwell with Josh Byrd
February 11, 2025

Balancing high performance in business, family, and fitness is no small feat, but Kathryn O’Day makes it look effortless. As a seven-time Ironman finisher and a venture capitalist, her approach to goal-setting and resilience offers valuable lessons for professionals looking to push their limits. After all, Ironman is one of the most challenging single-day…

Read More
Quantum Computing
Next-Gen Logistics: How Quantum Computing Powers Smoother Shipping and Fewer Delays
February 11, 2025

Supply chains are more complex than ever, with companies managing vast networks of suppliers, transportation routes, and inventory systems. Traditional computing methods are reaching their limits, struggling to process massive datasets efficiently. But here, quantum computing can come to the rescue: By integrating live data from IoT-enabled traffic monitoring tools and vehicles, quantum systems…

Read More
HVAC
Revolutionizing Construction Efficiency with Tailored HVAC Solutions
February 10, 2025

Discover the influence of Polygon’s cutting-edge GDX-45 HVAC systems, showcased in the Solomia Project by Operations Manager, Kyle Mattingly. Facilitating both construction progress and workforce comfort, these systems are practical solutions for the challenges of construction environments. Overcoming Project Challenges In the ongoing pursuit of progress, constructions often face hitches requiring strategic problem-solving. During…

Read More