Skip to content
‹ Back to IndustriesSciences

Is a U.S.and China Space Race is Good for the Global Economy?

“That’s Debatable” is an interactive series on today’s most pressing issues. This week’s resolution: Is a U.S.-China space race good for humanity? Arguing for the motion are Physicist Avi Loeb and former NASA Scientist Bidushi Bhattacharya. Against the motion are Theoretical Physicist Michio Kaku and Observer Research Foundation Distinguished Fellow and Nuclear and Space Policy…

This story was produced through MarketScale. See how Sciences teams put it to work with Executive Thought Leadership.

By Sciences · · ExplorationNasaScienceSpace
Share

Key takeaways

01

“That’s Debatable” is an interactive series on today’s most pressing issues.

02

This week’s resolution: Is a U.S.-China space race good for humanity?

03

Arguing for the motion are Physicist Avi Loeb and former NASA Scientist Bidushi Bhattacharya.

Free workspace

Turn your Sciences expertise into content.

Record interviews, organize footage, and write with AI on a free trial of the MarketScale platform for qualifying companies. No demo required, no credit card.

Try it Free

“That’s Debatable” is an interactive series on today’s most pressing issues. This week’s resolution: Is a U.S.-China space race good for humanity? Arguing for the motion are Physicist Avi Loeb and former NASA Scientist Bidushi Bhattacharya. Against the motion are Theoretical Physicist Michio Kaku and Observer Research Foundation Distinguished Fellow and Nuclear and Space Policy Initiative head Raji Rajagopalan.

Follow us on social media for the latest updates in B2B!

Twitter – @MarketScale

Facebook – facebook.com/marketscale

LinkedIn – linkedin.com/company/marketscale

Video TranscriptExpand ↓

Commercial rocket ships, a lunar outpost, expeditions to Venus and Mars, the Second Golden Age of space is upon us. Space is that intimate frontier. Dozens of nations are looking to the stars, but one in particular is gaining ground on what has been US preeminence. Before 2003, China had yet to put a human in space. A lot has changed. A potential trillion market is now up for grabs. And Beijing's ambitions are growing. We should be very afraid of a US China space competition and its consequences for all of us, as are those of private entrepreneurs, just like we are Facebook and Google. Now, the powerhouses in the future are going to be huge space companies. Perhaps a new space race will kick start with JFK once called the best of our energies and skills. But there are dangers, competition between great powers could unleash new military posturing with grave consequences. It'll escalate, of course, to a potential nuclear confrontation. So is a US China space race. Good for humanity? Join us for that, that's debatable, presented by Bloomberg and intelligence squared. From Washington, d.c., I'm John donvan, your host and moderator, welcome to that's debatable. An interactive series on today's most pressing issues. We have four space luminaries to debate. This resolution is a US China space race. Good for humanity? They take questions from me and our global audience, which votes to choose the winner. The team arguing against miccio kaku, a best selling author, theoretical physicist and a co-founder of string field theory, and rajai rajagopalan, a distinguished fellow and head of the nuclear and space policy initiative at the observer research foundation, one of India's leading think tanks. Their opponents, Avi Loeb, a physicist who was the longest serving astronomy chair at Harvard, and badush Bhattacharya, a former Nasa scientist turned entrepreneur. She oversees global businesses and space education and startup incubation. Let's go to their opening statements. The development of outer space is inevitable, not just in the United States. And China, but in nations that have a per capita GDP. That's just 3% that of the US. They are becoming space leaders. This is not just governments around the world. It's also private companies and startups. The price tag for space tech has dropped by a factor of up to 1,000. Access to outer space is indeed democratized. Space based goods and services are exponentially growing, and it's a global sector. Let's figure out how to cooperatively manage its development. A cooperative alliance that pulls expertise from around the world would allow the United States to access goods and services that we can work on this alone. Let's be clear about this space being democratized and exponential change is inevitable. Would a US China space race be good for humanity, or would it necessarily lead to the rapid misallocation of resources for possible militarization of space? I don't think the latter will happen. I believe any space race will very quickly move into military competition and US China space competition will now be no different. Second point, I think the US China space race cannot be limited to just the two players. This will spread. This will have cascading effects. Third point, which is we are already facing serious problems in space, crowded, congested, and the space race, it's already distrustful and the usable areas and outer space is fairly limited. And we need, therefore, restraint in our activities, the kind of activities that we engage in. This means we also need to bring about multilateral governance, global rules, global rules of the road, global agreements. But this would require, first and foremost, multilateral negotiations and the key negotiating body. The conference on disarmament, based in Geneva, has been stalemated for more than two decades. In fact, the last negotiations happened in 1996. And I think even though we do have a few treaties in place, we need updating some of the existing measures, such as the Outer Space Treaty of 1967. We need to change the rules of the road for global governance. Otherwise we will be essentially making space sustainability a serious threat. In the coming years. In general. Competition is good both for science, technology and humanity more generally. Now, the competition between nations started in the oceans. Imagine forbidding ships to leave Europe in fear of the use of ships for military purposes. Where will you be today? The other point to keep in mind is that it's impossible to enforce space laws, especially in the private sector. Since the private sector is outside the boundary of countries. Space is the ultimate frontier and it's also important for national security. We cannot assume cooperation by other nations. And we must protect our national interests. There is a strategic advantage operating from space for surveillance satellites, Warning systems for ballistic missiles, monitoring and cleaning up space debris, and monitoring existential risks, such as climate change, pollution or weather patterns. Anyone arguing against competition signals an inferiority complex, and I do believe that the US and its partners will and should win the competition as we did with the Soviet Union. And obviously, there are concerns, but we should move forward with our aspirations. I'm a professor of theoretical physics, but I. They also realized the physics can be used for peace as well as warfare. We're talking about the fact that our missiles travel at 18,000 miles per hour. Within a matter of minutes, you can knock off the enemy's satellites, communication systems, power systems and create havoc and paralyze and blind the enemy, which gives incentive for a first strike. Because if you strike first, you can blind the enemy if you strike. Second, you may not survive the strike second. Second of all, it will escalate, of course, to a potential nuclear confrontation. But there's a wild card. The wild card is the electromagnetic pulse. Back in the 1960s, the United States sent Hathor missile over the Pacific, detonated a hydrogen bomb in outer space, and was shocked at the electromagnetic pulse, which paralyzed communications between San Francisco and Tokyo. Set up burglar alarms all over Hawaii. A small country like North Korea being outgunned can shoot a warhead over Kansas and potentially knock out a good fraction of our satellites and power systems in the United States. That's the great equalizer. And who's the most vulnerable if it goes to a first strike? We are over 50% of the satellites in orbit are tied to the US military or the US economy. And remember, a new arms race is brewing now. Hypersonic weapons, that's the name of the next round of competition, destabilizing weapons that are maneuverable, that travel up to 20 times the speed of sound. Let's not be naive. The Russians are working on it. The Chinese are working on it. We are working on hypersonic drone vehicles and a whole new arms race could start. So the window of opportunity is now. Now is the time for a treaty before hypersonic weapons destroy our chance for a piece in outer space.

Your experts belong here

Every story in MarketScale Sciences starts with a company putting its lab directors, applications scientists, and field specialists on the record. Buyers are already reading this topic. The only question is whose experts they find.

Lab and research buyers verify before they trial, and your scientists give them something credible to verify against.

Book DemoSee how it works15 minutes, straight to a calendar.

About the author

S
Sciences
B2B Weekly

The week in Sciences, and sixteen other industries, every Monday.

Ten stories, one-line takes, five minutes. Free.

Sciences: are you visible to AI?

Before they reach out, Sciences buyers ask AI engines which vendors to trust. Explore how your experts, customers, and partners can become useful content for buyers and AI search.

Free Trial

You just read one Sciences expert. Your company is full of them.

This article was produced through MarketScale. The same platform turns your lab directors, applications scientists, and field specialists into the articles, video, and social content Sciences buyers are searching for. Start a free trial and see it with your own people. For qualifying companies, no credit card, no demo required.

NPS +73 · 1,000+ creators · 38+ countries

What your free trial includes

Hands-on access to the MarketScale platform
Media requests to your crowd, remote recording, AI writing tools
No demo required. No credit card.
For qualifying companies. Company confirmation required.

More Sciences Insights

PharmaLogic buys Lantheus' New Jersey radiopharma plant with a supply deal attached

PharmaLogic buys Lantheus' New Jersey radiopharma plant with a supply deal attached

PharmaLogic is buying Lantheus' contract manufacturing unit and Springfield, New Jersey radiopharmaceutical plant, plus a long-term deal to make lutetium Lu 177 dotatate for Lantheus. Radioligand developers looking for capacity should ask how much of the plant's capacity is still open.

  • 01A long-term supply contract attached to a plant sale could help keep costly hot-cell capacity in use. According to Grand View Research, committed supply agreements are among the tools that help providers align capital spending with customer development milestones.
  • 02Radioligand developers evaluating PharmaLogic's Agilera unit should ask how much Springfield capacity the lutetium Lu 177 dotatate contract will take up and how much is left for new programs.
  • 03Two pending transactions shape what to watch next: regulatory review and closing conditions for the PharmaLogic purchase, and Curium’s August offer of upward of $8 billion for Lantheus, which is still closing.

Nov 18, 2026

Merck KGaA moves Rapid Micro’s Growth Direct from distribution to ownership for QC labs

Merck KGaA moves Rapid Micro’s Growth Direct from distribution to ownership for QC labs

Merck KGaA agreed to buy Rapid Micro Biosystems, maker of the Growth Direct microbial testing platform, for $0.75 per share in cash. The deal turns a 2025 distribution partnership into ownership. Growth Direct instruments, consumables and software would then come from the company that already sells QC products to pharma labs, pending a December 2026 close.

  • 01Growth Direct shifts from a Merck-distributed product, under a February 2025 agreement, to a Merck-owned one inside a QC portfolio that spans environmental monitoring, in-process and release testing.
  • 02For labs that already run Growth Direct alongside MilliporeSigma QC products, the useful question is how the platform's digital sample records will connect to the rest of that workflow after close.
  • 03The next date to watch is the Schedule TO filing that opens the tender offer; closing targeted for December 2026 requires a majority of Rapid Micro’s voting shares to be tendered.

Nov 17, 2026

SR-Tiget gene therapy families average six months in Milan, with years of follow-up testing

SR-Tiget gene therapy families average six months in Milan, with years of follow-up testing

Gene therapy at Milan’s SR-Tiget includes a family support programme that helps relatives manage months-long stays (often around six months) for treatment, while a regulated lab can track patient samples for up to 20 years. Follow-up visits can outnumber new treatments, adding to the long-term workload.

  • 01In 2025, the programme logged 133 follow-up visits against 17 treatments; with roughly 15 years of twice-yearly checkups per patient, the follow-up load is likely to keep growing even if new treatments stay flat.
  • 02At SR-Tiget, the average family spends six months in Milan, and the child's samples can keep reaching the lab for as long as twenty years.
  • 03A practical question for gene therapy services: who alerts the lab when a child’s fever delays a blood draw? At SR-Tiget, research nurses manage the patient schedule and coordinate sample timing with the lab.

Nov 16, 2026

Explore More Sciences Insights

Read more expert perspectives from across Sciences.

Browse Sciences Hub

About the Expert

S
Sciences

For B2B teams

Your experts could be publishing here

Stories like this one run on content MarketScale captures from real practitioners. See how your team's expertise becomes coverage in Sciences and beyond.

Book a Demo

Or call us. No forms required. We pick up. 214-945-2512