Why Learning Matters More Than Grades: Purpose-Driven Teaching That Prioritizes Growth

Learning matters more than grades. In this episode of the Professional Quotient: Conversations that Build Equity, host Jason Winningham sits down with Jacob Mutchler, a high school calculus teacher whose path to the classroom took a few unexpected turns—from English major to hotel worker to passionate math educator committed to purpose-driven teaching.

Jacob shares how his love of learning and heart for underserved communities shaped his career, and why he believes compassion—not just credentials—is what moves the needle in education. With wisdom from the front lines of the classroom, he offers insights into what it really means to teach, the power of second chances, and how staying committed to your calling can change lives—even your own.

Key Takeaways from the Conversation:

• Every Student Can Learn Math: Jacob emphasizes that calculus isn’t just for the mathematically gifted—any student can succeed with the right support, clear explanations, and a learning-focused mindset.

• Teaching is Rooted in Compassion: Beyond subject mastery, the role of a teacher is deeply relational. Jacob shares how his compassion for students, particularly those from disadvantaged backgrounds, sustains his passion for purpose-driven teaching.

• Grades Aren’t the Goal—Growth Is: From adapting his teaching style to celebrating unexpected student insights, Jacob advocates for a classroom culture that rewards curiosity, perseverance, and continuous growth over letter grades.

Whether you’re an aspiring educator, a lifelong learner, or someone reflecting on the impact of your own teachers, this episode offers a powerful reminder: success isn’t just about the final grade—it’s about the human growth behind it.

Jacob Mutchler is a seasoned educator currently teaching calculus and pre-calculus. He began his career with a degree in English but transitioned into math after realizing his strengths and preference for the objectivity of the subject. With a deep commitment to serving under-resourced communities, Jacob leveraged scholarship opportunities to earn his math teaching credentials and now teaches in South Dallas. He is also an advocate for the AP program and believes in providing all students with the opportunity to earn college credit in high school. His teaching philosophy is driven by a lifelong love of learning and a strong sense of mission.