Case Study: Benefits of Post-Acute Nursing Facility vs. Home Care

When a patient is released from the hospital, patient advocates often believe their best chance for recovery and avoidance of readmission is in-home medical care and rehabilitation versus admittance into a skilled nursing facility (SNF). During hospitalization, however, it’s challenging to envision the in-home post-acute care needs for each unique patient. Thus, it’s not a simple narrative on which option will best facilitate a quick and full recovery.

The Determining Factors

To gain better insight, a study by Penn State University Leonard Davis Institute of Health Economics (LDI) looked to determine the differences in 30-day readmission rates, 30-day mortality rates, functional outcomes, and Medicare costs between those patients discharged to home health and those to an SNF. The assessment factors were unique in that the research used a large data set (17 million Medicare beneficiary hospitalizations), controls for patient characteristics across care settings, and included patients with many different ailments.

The Findings

During 2010 and 2016, of the more than 17 million discharges considered in the study, over 40% of the patients received some type of post-acute services—39% were released into a home care setting and 61% to an SNF. While those discharged to home rehab had a 5.6% higher readmission rate at 30 days than those in the SNF category, it is assumed that the 24-hour monitored care and higher level of treatment provided by an SNF reduced the likelihood of post-acute complications. However, the slightly higher readmission rates of home-recovery patients were not attributed to life-threatening symptoms such as respiratory failure but were based on potential cautionary reasons at the caregiver’s or patient’s discretion.

When it comes to costs, the average savings per patient discharged to in-home care was $5,385 less than patients admitted to SNFs. Further, the total Medicare payment within the first 60 days following hospitalization was also less for the home health care group, with a savings of $4,514 per patient. Interestingly enough, though, the study found no difference in improved patient functionality from the home health setting versus a SNF, nor were their disparities in mortality rates between each group. While the study correlates fewer readmissions with SNFs, these facilities did incur significantly increased Medicare spending per patient.

Clinicians must be able to balance the benefits of both settings to ensure the best outcome for their patients. Additional research to better understand which patient profiles would most benefit from SNF care or may be less likely to be readmitted after discharge to home health care could provide vital insight for caregivers and hospitals alike.

Help for Home Caretakers

When a patient is released to in-home care, their family or friends are often the ones tasked with helping in their recovery. This care typically involves changing dressings, managing medications, and the operation of fundamental medical equipment. AliMed is committed to providing patients and caregivers with a wide selection of quality at-home specialty healthcare products designed to improve quality of life and promote safer, easier, and more independent living. Click here to learn more.

Follow us on social media for the latest updates in B2B!

Image

Latest

belief
Learning Out Loud with Belief, Courage, and the Power of Yes
July 30, 2025

In a world where workplace disengagement is on the rise, with global employee engagement falling to just 21% in 2024, leaders and teams are increasingly seeking meaning, connection, and growth in their work. Amid this shift, professionals are asking deeper questions about purpose and fulfillment, both individually and collectively. That’s exactly where Paul Plamondon’s…

Read More
professional advancement
The Measured Mindset: How Mentorship, Curiosity, and Listening Drive Professional Advancement and Growth
July 29, 2025

Not every path into analytics starts with code and spreadsheets. For some, it begins with curiosity, adaptability, mentorship, and a willingness to learn something entirely new. That’s the case for Mayank Malviya, whose journey from a humanities education in India to a career in U.S.-based market research reveals how initiative and mentorship can accelerate…

Read More
future-ready workforce
Building a Future-Ready Workforce: Disrupting Outdated Education with Employer-Driven, Community-Powered, Practical Skills Training
July 28, 2025

Workforce training is undergoing a radical transformation as industries face critical talent shortages and rapid technological change. Building a future-ready workforce requires rethinking traditional higher education models. These models emphasize broad academic development over targeted skill-building and struggle to keep pace with employer demands. According to the World Economic Forum’s Future of Jobs Report…

Read More
The Silent Health Crisis: Indoor Air Quality in Long-Term Care
July 28, 2025

The Silent Health Crisis: Indoor Air Quality in Long-Term Care Most nursing homes have infection control down to a science. They’ve got medication protocols that would make a hospital jealous. Fall prevention? They track every risk factor. But ask them about their air quality and you’ll likely get a puzzled look. That’s a problem, because…

Read More