Should Consumers Trust Online Reviews?

Bringing together leaders, lawmakers and lawbreakers. Host Luke Fox explores how innovations in business and technology are redefining our trust in security measures.

Product reviews are essential in eCommerce, but how many of them are actually real? Fake reviews are a massive problem in the industry, but one website seeks to deliver transparency and accuracy on Amazon. The Trust Revolution host Luke Fox spoke with Tommy Noonan, founder of ReviewMeta. The website analyzes Amazon reviews and estimates which reviews to trust.

Noonan’s journey to ReviewMeta started in college when his roommate had bad side effects for a fitness supplement. Noonan scoured the web looking for reviews and didn’t find any.
“People need a trusted source of supplement reviews from consumers, rather than relying on what’s on the label. So I created a site for supplement reviews to bring this transparency, and it took off.”

It became a trusted source for millions but also noticed shady reviews. “Brands wanted to pretend to be consumers to write fake reviews. I began to research these suspicious reviews and removing them,” Noonan said.

Noonan soon learned that Amazon reviews were ripe with falsehoods. He then went through 580 reviews on one product as an analysis. Then he began writing a program to automate this, scraping the content from the reviews and analyzing them based on 15 different tests. That became ReviewMeta.

 

“We look for suspicious traits like unverified purchases and others and flag those. The program throws out anything that fails the tests. Then we recalculate the average rating and show that on our site.”

 

In the beginning, Noonan assumed that Amazon would fix the fake review situation. “I moved forward anyway, thinking the site would be obsolete. Instead, five years later, Amazon is getting worse, not better,” he added.

Amazon’s singular focus on revenue means tracing fake reviews isn’t a priority. They are to ReviewMeta, as they want to deliver accurate, honest information to consumers.

 

Catch Up On Previous Episodes of The Trust Revolution!

 

Follow us on social media for the latest updates in B2B!

Twitter – @MarketScale
Facebook – facebook.com/marketscale
LinkedIn – linkedin.com/company/marketscale

 

Follow us on social media for the latest updates in B2B!

Image

Latest

branding
Bonfire Branding: How Solo Stove Sparked a Customer Movement with Liz Vanzura (Episode One)
January 22, 2026

When pandemic restrictions shut down restaurants, paused travel, and compressed social lives, connection didn’t disappear; it moved closer to home. Backyards quietly emerged as important gathering spaces, offering a simple way to be together without screens, schedules, or spectacle. What began as a workaround evolved into a familiar rhythm of gathering. In that shift,…

Read More
customer movement
Bonfire Branding: How Solo Stove Sparked a Customer Movement with Liz Vanzura (Episode Three)
January 22, 2026

As audiences tune out polished ads and lean into trust, brands are being forced to rethink how they show up for the customer. Research consistently shows that consumers rate peer-created content as more credible than traditional brand messaging, and algorithmic discovery is increasingly rewarding authenticity over polish. With AI reshaping how people search and…

Read More
supply chains
Why the Best Careers Are Designed Like Resilient Supply Chains
January 22, 2026

What do supply chains and community have in common? They both deliver value—when managed with purpose. At their best, they show how intentional systems, meaningful connections, and consistent action turn effort into lasting professional growth. This week on Professional Quotient, listeners hear from Nathan Chaney, founder of Supply Chaney, whose insights bridge the mechanics…

Read More
brand
Bonfire Branding: How Solo Stove Sparked a Customer Movement with Liz Vanzura (Episode Two)
January 22, 2026

As people seek relief from constant digital noise, the backyard has quietly become a modern “third space” in everyday life. Outdoor living, fire pits, and at-home hosting continue to grow as consumers prioritize connection, ease, and experiences that feel meaningful without requiring more complexity. Brands that understand this shift aren’t just selling products—they’re offering…

Read More