What the Recent California Supreme Court Ruling Means for Our Industry

While some cases within the United States judicial system make headlines across the country, others get less coverage. Although the recent ruling in the Supreme Court of California on A1 Vs. Heckart didn’t make the front page of the major papers, it will have positive implications for On The Move, our customers, and the end consumer.

The Incident 

In June of 2012, Samuel Heckart rented a storage unit at one of A-1 Self Storage Inc.’s facilities. As part of his rental, Heckart agreed to pay $55 per month in rent and signed a contract, which included a document called “A-1 Self Storage Rental Agreement.”

Additionally, the storage company offered Heckart the opportunity to purchase liability coverage for the property that he stored in the unit for $10 more each month. The signed agreement said that if the tenant chose not to opt in to this coverage, he would have to provide proof of insurance within 30 days, and that failing to do so would automatically enroll him in the liability program. When Heckart did not provide proof of insurance, the storage company enrolled him in the plan as per the agreement.

The Lawsuit

In April of 2013, Heckart sued the storage company. His claim stated that the program is technically insurance, which A-1 Self Storage is not licensed to sell. Without getting too much in to the legal jargon, the case rested on whether or not protection policies like the one A-1 offered are insurance like you buy on your car or a protection policy like those you might get on a new television.

Over the next five years, courts throughout the California system heard arguments from both sides. Eventually, the case found its way into the Supreme Court of California. At the end of April 2018, the court issued its decision.

The Decision The state’s Supreme Court upheld the lower court’s decision that the protection plan did not qualify as insurance under California law. The court made a point to say that the agreement was between the storage company itself and renters. Since the policy is a service given to customers and not an indemnity, it is a protection plan.

The Consequences 

This is excellent news for storage unit owners and their customers. Without having to become licensed insurance brokers, storage unit owners can continue to offer protection at affordable rates to each of their customers.

At On The Move, we are thrilled to continue to offer a great protection plan for our customers. This ruling ensures that we can provide robust liability coverage. In fact, our customers can receive up to $5 million in coverage, and includes comprehensive and collision.

As a one-stop shop for all your truck needs, we look forward to offering the same excellent service and protection that our customers have come to expect.

Read more at onthemovetrucks.com

Follow us on social media for the latest updates in B2B!

Image

Latest

Commerce media
A Look at the Rise of Commerce Media Networks: How Nift Helps Brands Own How Their Message Shows Up
July 2, 2025

As traditional digital advertising struggles to retain consumer trust, brands are exploring new, more authentic ways to connect with shoppers. Platforms like commerce media networks, which weave together commerce, content, and data, are emerging as powerful tools in this shift. Research from MG2 Advisory reveals that only about 37% of consumers feel brands genuinely…

Read More
Hospitality leadership
Heart-First Hospitality Leadership: How Saying ‘Yes’ Transforms Guest Experiences, Boosts Staff Morale, and Drives Business Results
July 2, 2025

As the hospitality industry emerges from years of pandemic-driven upheaval, hospitality leadership is evolving to meet new challenges. Leaders are looking for new ways to retain staff, elevate guest satisfaction, and drive revenue without burning out their teams. One trend gaining traction is the power of “Yes”: empowering employees to say yes more often,…

Read More
civic leadership
Mayor Gerard Hudspeth’s Civic Leadership Journey: What Politics Teaches About People
July 2, 2025

What does a mayor learn about human nature? In this episode of Professional Quotient: Conversations that Build Equity, host Jason Winningham sits down with Gerard Hudspeth, longtime mayor of Denton, Texas, and a respected figure in civic leadership. Drawing from his years in public service, Hudspeth explores how leading a city reveals the core…

Read More
sepsis
Debunking Sepsis Myths – Episode 1
July 1, 2025

In the first episode of The Michael Rothman podcast, we address misconceptions about sepsis in healthcare. Although it’s often claimed that sepsis accounts for nearly a third of hospital deaths, many of these deaths are linked to chronic conditions with sepsis as a secondary factor. The frequently cited statistic that delays in treating sepsis increase…

Read More