How the Change in Reasonable Suspicion Policies Could Impact Employers

Reasonable suspicion for drug testing on the job changed recently under the new administration. To cover what’s new and provide tips for employers, Safety Justice League welcomed Adele Abrams, an attorney focusing on OSHA (Occupational Safety and Health Administration), MSHA (Mine Safety and Health Administration), and employee safety.

“Reasonable suspicion is a hot topic again under a new administration focused more on workers. It’s a hybrid issue—a little bit HR, safety, and DOT,” Abrams explained.

In 2016, the rules of testing post-injury had to include reasonable suspicion that the cause of it was drug-related. Failure to show this, and the employer could face fines. If found to be wrongfully tested, workers could be reinstated and receive back pay and benefits.

That practice ended during the Trump administration, allowing drug testing after an incident as long as it was part of a root cause investigation. Under Biden, the policy shifts back to the 2016 stance.

“OSHA is now looking at from the worker’s perspective. Prior, there was elimination of worker protections. Employers need to change their policy, or they can risk complaints,” Abrams said.

Abrams noted that whistleblowing could also apply to those making safety complaints. “If an employee makes a safety complaint, and they require a test, which is negative, the worker is protected. Even supervisors can face fines.”

Abrams’ advice to employers is to “be as objective as you can to avoid litigation.” Unfortunately, reasonable suspicion itself lends itself to being more subjective. “You can use a checklist to note what you’re observing about demeanor, appearance, and behavior. But you’ll need to apply it a meaningful way, which means knowing your workers and their normal behavior.”

More Stories Like This:

Psychological Health: The Often Hidden Side of Supporting a Healthy Workplace

How to Keep Safety First During a Skilled Labor Shortage

Follow us on social media for the latest updates in B2B!


Oil Producers Face a Long Haul Back to Business as Usual
World’s Most Watched Oil Data Won’t Be Released This Week
June 23, 2022
(Bloomberg) -- The most closely watched oil data in the world -- the US government’s Weekly Petroleum Status Report -- won’t be released as planned this week because of system issues stemming from a power Read more
Increasing Fuel Prices Will Not Stop Travel This Summer
June 23, 2022
It’s no secret that the past two years haven’t been easy on the travel industry. And when it seemed people were ready to venture out into the world again, rising fuel prices made a dent in those Read more
Highway to Health: Special Father’s Day Episode
June 23, 2022
  On this special episode of Highway to Health, David Kemp talks with his father, Lieutenant Colonel Dr. Kemp. Dr. Kemp followed his father into the Air Force. He expected to do it for a few Read more