High Turnover in Diversity Roles is a Reflection of Unrealistic Expectations

Diversity roles, specifically diversity and inclusion managers, have been the second fastest growing job title in the last five years according to LinkedIn. Yet, these positions are also experiencing a high turnover as many small- and high-profile businesses can attest to. Nike, one of the most visible in this trend of diversity roles jumping ship, just lost its most recent DEI executive hire after only six months on the job.

Is this because businesses over-emphasized the position after a wave of 2020 protests, social movements, and pressure on corporations to be more vocally progressive on social justice issues? Or was it always unrealistic to expect one hire alone to enhance company culture? President of Employers Advantage LLC, Deanna Baumgardner, reflects on her companies’ findings and emphasizes that, overall, companies’ expectations for this role have not been properly defined to be effective and keep hires engaged.

Deanna’s Thoughts

“It’s unfortunate, but it’s also not surprising that there’s an uptick in turnover in diversity roles right now. I think that there was a huge push by a lot of companies thinking this is what they needed to do, so they threw out some diversity job descriptions, and one of the things that we saw in some of the postings for diversity officers was it was a ‘mishmosh’ of a bunch of different stuff that really didn’t focus on the core of what needed to happen in that role.

The other thing is, again, it’s not something that happens overnight. It’s a complete shift in culture and there is a lot of learning and analysis and implementation and things that happen before a true culture, diversity, equity, and inclusion can even begin to happen. So, this isn’t something that a company can hire a person for, put in this role and then make it happen.

That’s just not how it works. It takes a lot of time, effort, and resources on behalf of everyone in the organization.”

Follow us on social media for the latest updates in B2B!



Empowering Through Connection: Vogel’s Pyramid Model Approach
July 19, 2024

Mission and Impact: Vogel Alcove, a nonprofit in Dallas, helps homeless children and families through various programs and services. Pyramid Model Framework: Vogel uses the Pyramid Model, an evidence-based framework for promoting young children’s social-emotional development with universal supports, targeted supports, and intensive interventions. Nurturing Relationships and Supportive Environments: Vogel focuses on building nurturing…

Read More
MedPAC’s Miss on Reality of Home Health Financial Reality Results in Suggested Cut in 2025 Proposed Rule
July 19, 2024

The March 2024 MedPAC report recommending a 7% payment reduction for home health agencies in 2025 has sparked significant concern within the industry. Why is this recommendation being met with such resistance, and what does the financial reality of home health agencies look like in contrast to these federal suggestions? Are the MedPAC recommendations…

Read More
baseball game
Sixth Inning- What are the Stages Where Your Business Takes Place?
July 18, 2024

When you think of a baseball game, you might picture the crack of the bat or the roar of the crowd as a home run sails over the outfield fence. But for the Savannah Bananas, the game is just one part of the spectacle. Jesse Cole, the mastermind behind this innovative team, shares how…

Read More
skilled trades career
A Skilled Trades Career Provides a Future-Proof Path
July 18, 2024

In today’s rapidly changing job market, a skilled trades career offers a viable and attractive option, especially for the younger generations exploring alternatives to traditional college education. Recent trends indicate a significant shift in interest in these hands-on professions. On Straight Outta Crumpton, host Greg Crumpton engages in a lively conversation with Nicole Bass,…

Read More