As Google Cancels its Banking Plans, Why Has Big Tech Struggled in the FinTech Arena?

 

Key Points:

  • Google Pay cancels its digital banking service Plex after internal disruptions.
  • Ranking third amongst mobile payment players, Google Pay boasts around 25 million users in 2021.
  • If even Google couldn’t make a dent, how should companies disrupt the digital banking space?

Commentary:

Google Pay has had a tough year, with the departure of dozens of employees from the division and its revamp into a full personal finance service platform facing mixed reviews. It can now add a dead app to that list. Google’s plan for a digital banking service and the standardization of Google Bank Accounts is now cancelled, as the company puts an end to its Plex service.

The vision for Plex was supposed to a mobile first banking app with a physical ecosystem of credit and debit cards, and a leveraging of the Google ecosystem and UI to make for an innovative visual, responsive, and integrated banking service. The 400,000 people on Plex’s waitlist will stay waiting. As the service moves into the past, we wanted to ask: What went wrong? Why have private companies outside of fintech struggled to disrupt and democratize banking? And where should disruptors place their focus to enhance and simplify the experience of personal finance?

David Shipper, Senior Strategic Advisor for the Retail Banking & Payments practice at Aite-Novarica Group, pulled from his experience surrounding the financial ecosystem of debit, credit, and prepaid cards to give a detailed analysis.

Abridged Thoughts:

So Google scrapping plans to offer a checking account or deposit account directly to consumers actually makes a lot of sense. It’s a very competitive market and you’ll see we already see many players, tech companies or startup card programs or new online only accounts.

Many players are coming into this market and many of them are struggling to gain and retain accounts. And I would say really, there’s two main issues two main hurdles that are very difficult for these new players to overcome.

One is competing with a brick and mortar location is consumers will tell you often that they want the most innovative product. They want the absolute coolest, best account or card or rewards program that’s available. But at the end of the day, they also want to be able to visit their local bank or use an ATM without a fee or open in other types of accounts and sit down with someone. Those those benefits of having physical location nearby are very difficult to offset with an online only account.

The other hurdle that you’ll see for anyone, whether it’s Google or any other company attempting or wanting to sell a financial product, is that that movement or that action by the consumer to move their direct deposit, moving the direct deposit, moving bill, pay billers, making those kind of transitions? That’s a very difficult hurdle to get a consumer to do and consumers have to actually work for that.

Follow us on social media for the latest updates in B2B!

Image

Latest

No Fail Trust Methodology
Empowering Teams with the No Fail Trust™ Methodology: Insights From U.S. Air Force Pilot Jason O. Harris
February 7, 2025

On this episode of the Through the Storm podcast, Dr. Travis Hearne speaks with Retired U.S. Air Force Pilot, Global Keynote Speaker, and all-around badass, Jason O. Harris. Lieutenant Colonel Jason Harris is a highly sought-after keynote speaker, best-selling author, expert thought leader, and professional pilot. As a fourth-generation military member, Jason’s distinguished career…

Read More
The Art of Communication in Disaster Recovery: Building Trust and Delivering Results
The Art of Communication in Disaster Recovery
February 6, 2025

In this episode of Inside Restoration and Recovery, host Martha Lewis sits down with Chris Matthews, Regional Director for Large Loss at BMS CAT, to explore the critical role of communication, preparation, and adaptability in disaster recovery. Chris shares his personal journey in the restoration industry, including his passion for helping clients during their…

Read More
women’s health
AI and Advocacy Unite: Tackling Women’s Health Disparities with Hologic Mia Keeys
February 5, 2025

Women’s health remains a critical issue globally, with alarming disparities in access and outcomes. A new survey from Hologic and Gallup reveals that while nearly 90% of women recognize the importance of health screenings, less than half undergo them consistently due to barriers like cost, time, and anxiety. The stakes are particularly high in…

Read More
toast
The Framework Series Advantage: Using Toast to Visualize and Refine Business Processes
February 5, 2025

Most organizations face challenges when aligning teams on processes and strategies. According to a 2021 McKinsey Global Survey, fewer than one-third of companies successfully improve performance and sustain those improvements over time, often due to a lack of employee engagement and poor execution. The key to overcoming this? A simple exercise involving sticky notes and…

Read More