Skip to content
MarketScale
‹ Back to IndustriesRetail

How to Prevent Your Retail Segment from Becoming the Next “Bookstore”

As is the case in many other industries, independent wine and spirit retailers in a post-COVID world are seeing a drop in sales and revenue. The reason? The shifting demands of online shoppers has reduced their desire to discover new brands. Mike Provance, the CEO of 3×3, works to change that. 3×3 is a…

This story was produced through MarketScale. See how Retail teams put it to work with Sales Enablement.

Share

As is the case in many other industries, independent wine and spirit retailers in a post-COVID world are seeing a drop in sales and revenue. The reason? The shifting demands of online shoppers has reduced their desire to discover new brands.

Mike Provance, the CEO of 3×3, works to change that. 3×3 is a marketing technology company dedicated to helping independent liquor retailers engage with and market to consumers. He joins Melissa Gonzalez to discuss how 3×3 leverages data to develop hyper-targeted, hyper-local marketing strategies for these independent retailers.

By drawing on their own proprietary data drawn from over 1,500 stores, information on demographics from a third-party source, as well as each store’s own demographic and profile attributes, 3×3 creates a powerful modeling tool to help clients zero in on their target audience.

One surprising trend Provance has noted in the post-COVID consumer’s online shopping habits is that they tend to have larger baskets, but go longer between purchases.

This shift hurts independent retailers the most, because the majority of these purchases tend to be from big household brands that are more easily found online. So although the total amount people are spending online isn’t changing, factors like replenishment cycles and inventory mix are.

Provance also noticed that customers shopping online prioritize speed and convenience — shoppers will often make alcohol purchases from the first page of a store’s online catalog, focusing on familiar names instead of trying something new. He adds that alcohol retailers haven’t built the right infrastructure to support online discovery, and that’s costing them dearly right now.

In the future, the 3×3 CEO expects brands to curate a personalized digital shopping experience for their consumers. Smaller and mid-market brands must start thinking about how they can stand out online in that regard.

Listen To Previous Episodes of Retail Refined Right Here!

Retail: are you visible to AI?

Before they reach out, Retail buyers ask AI engines which vendors to trust. See how AI describes your company today, and where competitors show up instead.

Free workspace

You just read one Retail expert. Imagine publishing your whole team.

This article was produced through MarketScale. Create a free workspace and turn your own team's Retail expertise into the articles, video, and social content B2B marketing buyers in your industry are searching for. No credit card, no demo required.

NPS +73 · 1,000+ creators · 38+ countries

What you get, free

Your own MarketScale Studio workspace
One video edit a month, on us
AI writing, editing, and publishing tools
In-platform coaching to learn the system

More Retail Insights

Instacart's Arpalus acquisition signals AI-driven shelf intelligence is now table stakes for grocery operators

Instacart's Arpalus acquisition signals AI-driven shelf intelligence is now table stakes for grocery operators

Instacart has acquired Arpalus, a firm specializing in computer vision, as part of its strategy to enhance AI-driven shelf intelligence. This move emphasizes the growing importance of AI technology in the retail and grocery sectors to improve efficiency and customer experience. As AI continues to reshape ecommerce, grocery operators need to integrate these technologies to remain competitive.

  • 01Instacart has acquired Arpalus to integrate advanced computer vision technology into its platform.
  • 02AI-driven shelf intelligence is becoming essential for modern grocery and retail operations.
  • 03Grocery operators must evaluate and adopt AI technologies to stay competitive in the changing retail landscape.

Jul 31, 2026

Retail's digital infrastructure is being rebuilt in real time, and Tractor Supply, Albertsons, and DoorDash are showing how

Retail's digital infrastructure is being rebuilt in real time, and Tractor Supply, Albertsons, and DoorDash are showing how

Major retailers like Tractor Supply, Albertsons, and DoorDash are actively rebuilding their digital infrastructure amid the growing e-commerce market, projected to reach $6.9 trillion globally by 2026. Retailers are adopting new strategies to enhance their digital operations and meet increasing customer demands. These efforts highlight the ongoing changes in the retail landscape driven by technological advancements.

  • 01E-commerce is expected to grow to a $6.9 trillion global market by 2026.
  • 02Retailers are enhancing their digital operations to adapt to technological advancements.
  • 03Companies like Tractor Supply, Albertsons, and DoorDash are leading in digital infrastructure redevelopment.

Jul 31, 2026

Amazon Business hits $60 billion in annualized gross sales as B2B ecommerce enters its agentic AI era

Amazon Business hits $60 billion in annualized gross sales as B2B ecommerce enters its agentic AI era

Amazon Business has reached a milestone of $60 billion in annualized gross sales as the use of agentic AI transforms how enterprise buyers find and purchase products. The integration of AI in B2B ecommerce is facilitating more efficient product discovery and procurement processes for businesses. This marks a significant evolution in the B2B retail landscape, emphasizing the growing influence of technology in commerce.

  • 01Amazon Business achieved $60 billion in annualized gross sales.
  • 02Agentic AI is changing how enterprise buyers discover and purchase products.
  • 03B2B ecommerce is increasingly adopting advanced technologies like AI.

Jul 30, 2026

Explore More Retail Insights

Read more expert perspectives from across Retail.

Browse Retail Hub

For B2B teams

Your experts could be publishing here

Stories like this one run on content MarketScale captures from real practitioners. See how your team's expertise becomes coverage in Retail and beyond.

Book a 15-minute demo

Or call us. No forms required. We pick up. 214-945-2512